Saturday, February 21, 2015

Commonwealth v. Carman -- The Kentucky Supreme Court's 20 Pages of Trees

In the category of "can't see the forest for the trees" is a Kentucky Supreme Court opinion discussing bail in that state. Here's a link to the opinion:

http://opinions.kycourts.net/sc/2013-SC-000684-CL.pdf

You may recall that Kentucky has no commercial sureties; indeed, that state declared them unlawful in the 1970s. Nevertheless, Kentucky still apparently relies on money, as this case amply illustrates.

If you read the opinion, you'll find yourself digesting about 20 pages of trees -- details about when judges can set bail, alter bail, do things ex parte (hint: as a rule of thumb, it's universally hardly ever to never) -- but if you get that deep into it, you'll lose that elusive forest. I'll use the easiest defendant, one Shannandoah Carman, to illustrate.

Carman was assessed by the pretrial services program to be someone who could be released on his own recognizance (i.e., without paying a secured financial condition). The judge on "duty" that day nonetheless decided instead to condition Carman's release on paying $1,000 in cash, and set his arraignment for the next day. The next morming, however, a new judge, who was apparently neither the new duty judge nor the judge who would ultimately be assigned the case, took it upon himself to release Carman on his own recognizance, meaning that the judge either changed the financial amount to nothing, or that he made the amount what we call an "unsecured amount," meaning that it only had to be paid on the back-end in the event that Carman didn't show up for court. This change, whichever it was, allowed for the immediate release of Carman because he was no longer required to pay money up-front to get out of jail.

This angered the prosecutors (and possibly the first judge), and thus began the long appeal over what the second judge did and how he did it. In the end, you have an opinion that lays down some rules about what judges can and can't do in Kentucky. But let's step back and check out that forest.

When the first judge set a cash bond, he did so against the recommendation of the pretrial services assessment (which apparently stated that Carman could be safely managed in the community, and that a cash condition would not help in any way), the pretrial research (which shows that money doesn't matter for either court appearance or public safety, that secured bonds only detain people unnecessarily, and that even short-term detention periods of a day or two can make certain defendants and society less safe for no good reason), the national best practice standards (which dissuade judges from using secured bonds altogether), and the law (which says that adding a secured financial condition to a bond "just to be sure" is excessive and the resulting detention is a violation of procedural due process). By simply releasing Carman with no financial condition (or by changing the secured financial condition to an unsecured one, if that's what happened) the second judge actually did substantively what was right, just, and lawful. Something we all really want our judges to do.

Now, he didn't do it the way it he should have (that's more of the detail found in the trees, and concerning this particular issue the trees start to appear a bit weird and sleazy), but the point is that if the first judge actually wanted to follow legal and evidence-based practices at bail, he would have set a recognizance or unsecured appearance bond to begin with. The opinion doesn't say so, but I'll bet five dollars that money wasn't the only condition of release for Carman; there were likely a bunch of what we call non-financial conditions that would do quite well at providing reasonable assurance of public safety and court appearance. But, as you all know by now, money is the thing that keeps people in jail, starts all the bad things happening, and triggers lawsuits and appeals.

Overall, this "forest" in this case illustrates something that happens a lot in America. Judges who don't know better (or don't care) will cling to outdated and potentially unlawful practices due to custom, habit, and, sometimes, outspoken prosecutors.

Which reminds me, what about the prosecutors in this matter -- the ones who were ethically bound to "do justice" in the case and who argued vehemently throughout this process and appeal for the cash condition on Carmen's bond? Well, in the end, they dismissed all charges against Carman. Now just think about that for a minute, and realize that there's something catastrophically wrong with a system that would tolerate keeping a person in jail by using money, endure arguing, ad nauseam, that the person "needs" an irrational, arbitrary, and destructive condition of release, like money, and then condone the ultimate dismissal of that persons's case at some later date without anyone even hinting at the injustice that would have occurred had Carman not been released pretrial.    

Kentucky is rightfully being hailed as a state that is further along than most when it comes to bail reform. Nevertheless, as this case readily shows (and, really, like everywhere else), it still has a bit further to go.    

       

Saturday, February 14, 2015

The Evolving Views of the Bail Insurance Companies



It used to be that two of the most ridiculous statements ever made by bail insurance company lobbyists (you remember them ... they're the ones who get paid humongous fees to make sure we keep money bail in place) are these: (1) there's no such thing as people being in jail because they can't afford to pay money; and (2) there's no presumption of innocence at bail. These aren't the only two, but they're biggies, and so I figured that eventually they'd have to start spinning their way out of them.

Well, just recently I read an online article by a big bail insurance company, and it premised its whole shtick on the presumption of innocence. Man, that's a pretty big reversal. Somewhere on this same company's website is another, older article, in which a lobbyist for the same company went to great pains to explain why criminal defendants are not presumed innocent at bail. Knowing this company, it's probably still on there because it doesn't even recognize when it contradicts itself anymore.

So that's one extraordinarily ridiculous statement recanted, and one more to go.

Just remember that the issue we all face with bail and no bail is money. If you're not thinking about money -- what to do with it and whether you even need it -- you aren't doing pretrial justice "justice."

Bondsmen aren't the problem. They're just using an antiquated, unfair, and opaque system to try to make a living. Most bail agents I have met are great people, and they believe deeply in the right to bail. The insurance lobbyists, though, are something quite different. One day they'll say there's no presumption of innocence, and the next day they'll say there is. They'll tell you just about anything to keep you from rationally thinking about money. And that's because if we start thinking about money rationally, they may not get their cut.

Monday, January 19, 2015

Bail and No Bail Two Years Later

Two years ago, I posted my first blog on Martin Luther King Jr. Day, and I drew comparisons between the civil rights movement and the movement today for pretrial justice. Two years later, we've made progress, but not enough.

When I started working on bail and no bail, the biggest comment I received was the well-worn, "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" comment. Thankfully, I think we've moved past that, and now I think that just about everyone understands that there are quite a few things concerning pretrial release and detention that really need some work. Still, I've spent the better part of eight years trying to get people to understand those issues and to improve on their own. That approach has worked in a few places, but I think the time has come to start pushing a bit harder.

So consider what's going to happen next to be a little like the civil rights marches in the 1960s. Those marches tended to force certain issues, so that people who wouldn't normally change on their own had to at least consider it. Our pretrial "marches," however, are going to be in the form of federal suits challenging state bail practices. Believe me, if you aren't ready for it, one of those lawsuits is really going to throw you for a loop. And once the federal courts start speaking with one voice, there's no place in America that can avoid pretrial reform.

Okay, you've been warned.


 

  

Saturday, January 3, 2015

Two Histories of Bail?

When I started researching bail, I noticed that there wasn't much on the history of bail. Accordingly, I started reading everything about the history, and I ended up writing quite a bit about it. It turns out that the history tells you some pretty important things, like why we've needed bail reform and how to avoid needing bail reform in the future.

Yesterday I noticed another published "history of bail" in Springer's Encyclopedia of Criminology and Criminal Justice. I couldn't wait to read it, especially since it was written by what I call a "bail insurance company sympathizer." I won't go into all the gory details of that right now, but maybe I will in the future if I have to.

In any event, I was anxious to see what the bail industry take on the history might be. After all, if you look at the history of bail, the commercial surety industry looks pretty bad. We only created that industry in 1900 (ironically because we thought it would reduce the numbers of people in jail who couldn't get out through the previous personal surety system), and by 1920 we had our first decent paper (written by the Dean of the Harvard Law School and a future Supreme Court Justice) saying that we need to figure out ways to stop using bondsmen. Ever since, they've been causing chaos with release and detention in America. Everyone from bail scholars and historians to police officers and judges have criticized them, and whenever anyone writes anything good about that business, it becomes pretty clear that the author was either paid off or didn't do his or her homework.

The bondsmen's history probably leaves out the fact that several states have completely eliminated them (the industry continues to try to get back into those states using some very slippery tactics), ignores the fact that the ABA national best-practice standards on pretrial release and detention calls for the abolition of the commercial surety industry, and uses the same four or five studies (most of which have been rendered useless through a Department of Justice data advisory, but that's whole other blog) to try to convince people to keep using them.

The bondsmen's history probably doesn't mention anything about the rampant abuse in the industry (documented starting in the 1920s), with commercial sureties trading bonds for sex, failing to pay for forfeited amounts, bilking clients, and knocking down the doors of random houses looking for what they call their "skips." It probably won't focus too much on their intense affiliation with ALEC, the same black bag policy group that fought against protecting children from cigarettes, that works hard to disenfranchise voters, and that continues to try to get courts across America to use commercial bail bondsmen no matter how many people it harms. And I doubt it'll go into much detail about just how much money the insurance companies make from this whole arrangement. So much money, in fact, that they have no problem spending millions on lobbyists to make sure that our system of bail continues to generate a profit.

So I was looking forward to reading it, you know?

The problem is that there was no way to buy just that article. Apparently you have to buy the whole freakin' encyclopedia just to read about the history of bail.

So . . .  I guess I'll leave a proper critique of the substance for another day. For now, just realize that there are two histories out there -- and they might not look exactly alike. I'll let you all decide which to believe. The histories that I helped to write are free, and you can find them in both our "History of Bail" document or in my recent "Fundamentals of Bail" document, both of which are on the National Institute of Corrections' and the Pretrial Justice Institute's websites. The bondsmen history is for sale at the low price of only $4,350.00 on the Springer Publishing website.

That kind of seems like a lot of money, but really it makes a lot of sense. Bondsmen, bail insurance lobbyists, and bail industry sympathizers don't think twice about making all of us pay big money simply to get out of jail, when freedom and liberty are our basic human rights. What's $4,000 for a couple of books?

Friday, January 2, 2015

Bail and the Media -- Again

I've written about this before, so I'll be short.

This is the time when media outlets start listing all of the big important news stories that happened over the last year. I was watching CNN the other day, and, as media outlets that must fill 24 hours each day probably have to do, they were discussing the relative merits of their particular list. One guy -- I can't remember who -- lamented that the media tended to focus only on sensational stories. His example was that during a recent spree of looting by about 100 people after a protest in California, the media showed footage of that particular chaotic event repeatedly. But, he said, when about 25,000 people in California marched peacefully later that week, there was no coverage. The funny thing was that while he was saying all of this, CNN again showed the footage of the looting, but not the peaceful march. Point proven.

This all reminded me of the two biggest mistakes the media can make in covering news stories about bail. The first is to focus only on the sensational story -- usually an aberrational case of pretrial misconduct -- that doesn't represent the vast majority of cases or that is shown without any sort of explanatory perspective. If all they did was simply add a line of perspective, media outlets would go quite far in reducing the amount of unnecessary fear they tend to whip up concerning crime.

The second is to think that if any particular bail story presents two sides, then that story is balanced. No, in bail, you typically have about 20 different, important, and valid sides to any particular story. But 19 of them will all basically say the same thing in different versions and with different perspectives. The twentieth, often the opinion of a bail industry or insurance lobbyist who hopes to make a few bucks, will be the opposite of everyone else.

Don't get me wrong. I love the media and I can't overstate it's importance. I majored in journalism in college and for several years I represented television, radio, cable and satellite clients in Washington, D.C. If you're a reporter, though, and you're working on a bail story, try to stay away from these two mistakes. Or just give me a buzz.

Happy New Year!

Sunday, December 7, 2014

Indiana and the Purpose of Bail


I just read a bail insurance company's take on bail in Indiana, which is worth a quick comment. In the insurance company's post, the writer opines that the purpose of bail is to guarantee that a defendant comes back to court. Then, interestingly, the same fellow laments that by using what we call a "ten-percent-option," which allows defendants to post ten percent of the financial condition of his or her bond to the court, rather than to a bondsman, the Indiana judges are taking money away from that state's "Common School Fund." Apparently, making the defendants pay money for release in ways other than the ten percent method directly subsidizes this fund.

This raises an important question -- just what is the purpose of bail? Is it court appearance or is it to finance the Common School Fund? The answer is neither one.

What we know as bail today was created in England in the Middle Ages, and when it was created, the purpose of bail was to avoid blood feuds between family clans. This remained the primary purpose of bail right up until the Normans changed everything by making the criminal process more of a public process, with crimes of royal concern (like today having criminal actions brought by the state), presentment juries, itinerant justices, and jails. Ever since, the purpose of bail has been exactly what logic would tell you it is when jails are involved: to release people. Bail is a process of release, and its purpose is to release people pretrial, just as "no bail" is a process of detention, and its purpose is to detain people pretrial. The insurance fellow in question is getting a condition of bail or release confused with bail itself. In America pretrial release is always conditional (with at least one condition being to come back to court or the bond might be revoked) and placing those conditions on a defendant's freedom may only be done to provide reasonable assurance of public safety or court appearance.

So the purpose of bail itself is to release people, and the purpose of conditioning that release on something is to provide reasonable assurance of one of the two constitutionally valid purposes of court appearance or public safety. When bail insurance people say that the purpose of bail is court appearance only, they are making that statement from their particular business angle. Bail bondsmen and the insurance companies simply do not have anything to do with public safety -- universally across America you can't even forfeit money on a bail bond for a new crime, and so for this and other reasons money simply does not protect the public. In fact, a defendant who continually commits crimes but never misses court is actually considered to be a pretty good customer to the commercial bail industry. Additionally, bail bondsmen will typically skip talking about release rates or any other notion of releasing people -- universally across America bondsmen and insurance companies reserve the right to deny helping any defendant to gain his or her release for any reason, or for no reason whatsoever.

If we know the purpose of bail (which is to release people) and the constitutionally valid purposes of conditions of release (which are either court appearance or public safety) then we know, too, that any other purpose for conditioning release is likely an invalid purpose. That's why nearly every state has articulated through case law various invalid purposes, and one of the most common is setting bail to "enrich the treasury," or something like that. It's pretty simple, really, if you can only condition release to protect the public or to assure court appearance, then conditioning release to pay for things is an invalid purpose. I doubt that the Indiana courts have said that a legitimate purpose for conditioning someone's pretrial freedom is to help pay for things, but if they have then it would be a complete aberration to what other courts have said across America. And even if it's not unlawful under Indiana law, one of these days someone will run a case up the federal side that will set everyone straight.

The way to look at the purpose of bail is to think of only three things -- release, court appearance, and public safety. Any other reason for setting a bail bond, whether expressly or not, is likely an invalid purpose. That's why you can't set bail to punish people (another clearly unconstitutional purpose) or to detain people, especially when avoiding the lawfully enacted detention process in any particular state. It's like setting bail to impress your friends. Invalid. And under nearly every big theory of law applicable to bail, whether that theory be due process, excessive bail, or equal protection, the government has to first articulate a proper purpose for its action.

If you don't believe me about all of this, go find an Indiana judge and get him or her to expressly state on the record that he or she is setting a particular amount of a financial condition in order to help pay for various state services. Run that decision up the appellate ladder -- both state and federal -- and see what happens.

I cover all of this in more depth in my Fundamentals of Bail paper, which you can find on my website. Oh, and I just noticed that I already talked about the same basic thing in a blog from 9-23-13. Obviously, the purpose of bail and setting bail for invalid purposes is one of those "bail basics" that I intend to revisit more than once.

Wednesday, November 26, 2014

Ferguson





Talking about Ferguson today isn't that big of a stretch for a guy specializing in bail reform. After all, a broad definition of bail as well as the concept of pretrial justice includes an officer's decision to release or detain, and, without even talking about the contact that initiated this whole thing, a whole bunch of people probably got detained in the last couple of days and nights after finding out that the Grand Jury wouldn't indict.

But I write today as someone who used to work in all areas of the criminal justice system, and who used to try to find answers to questions arising from all decision points. That and other experience in the system causes me to write very briefly about what must now be done: a complete examination of our criminal justice system and the methods we have created, nurtured, and perhaps taken for granted over the last century, and with that examination done by a body of people who didn't create this mess to begin with.

In a recent Time Magazine, Joe Klein explains how a certain type of police training -- one that was opposed by many people embedded in the current system -- could have entirely prevented the original shooting in Ferguson. My own experience with police training has illustrated to me that some communities will never experience the tensions underlying relationships in Ferguson because of the more progressive ways they hire and train officers, but try telling that to certain police agencies who have been training the same way (or in increasingly aggressive ways) for decades. I have seen first-hand abuses with the grand jury system, but getting a sitting prosecutor to recognize that abuse -- or even the clear appearance of abuse -- is nearly impossible.

And then there's bail. I've spent eight years now talking about how unfair it is to lock people up before their trials based on how much money they have, but criminal justice officials seem content with the whole thing. I once knew an elected prosecutor who repeatedly talked about how many years of experience he had in the justice system, but when it came to improving that system he was adamantly opposed. When the jail was full, he said that a full jail wasn't his problem. When we talked about pretrial justice, he said he didn't think anything was wrong. When we mentioned research, he actually said that he didn't believe in research. His experience, it turned out, was basically in screwing things up. For decades. And guess what? When the time came to create a group of experts to look at bail reform in Colorado, they put him on (well, he kind of forced his way on, but that's another story).

We need complete reform, and we can only accomplish that reform by intentionally leaving out many of the people responsible for the current broken system. It shouldn't be too hard to realize that a "blue ribbon commission," which is designed to stop current abuses, but which is comprised of those persons who tolerated those abuses for decades, is not the answer.

The other day I had an older gentleman who had been involved in criminal justice for decades try to argue with me about what he saw were the benefits of secured money bail -- the one thing that we know keeps people in jail unnecessarily due to their inability to produce it. The same day I heard from a twenty-something legislative aide who had decided simply to take secured money bail completely out of the state statute. The difference? If the first guy didn't actually cause some of the problems that we have today, he certainly tolerated them, or maybe even worse, didn't recognize them at all. The young aide had a clean slate.

Ferguson started with a human tragedy -- the death of Michael Brown -- and I am praying for Michael, his family, the community, the police, and everyone else who want sincerely to avoid human misery and suffering at every cost. The uprising in that city and in cities across the United States in the last couple of nights is a clear signal that the people of America are upset with the way our criminal justice system is playing out, and the need for some sort of reform, So, sure, look into reform and create a group to do it. Look into police training and tactics. Look into pretrial justice. Look into the grand jury system and other prosecutor practices. But leave out the people who aren't even sure why the citizens of Ferguson are upset. Leave out the people who think that the country is overreacting. Basically, leave out the people who caused all of our problems to begin with. They had their chance.