Yesterday the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals granted the motion of recently elected Harris County judges to dismiss their appeal of the preliminary injunction won by bail reformers last summer. You can read about it here.
As you recall, that's the earth shattering injunction that -- theoretically -- could change bail practices across the nation simply because Harris County practices look identical to those in virtually all American counties. I've been teaching on the injunction since it came out, and it's reasoning is nearly perfect.
This all means massive changes to misdemeanor bail in Harris County, but the same arguments apply to felonies, and it's just a matter of time before people understand that.
One outgoing judge quoted in the article said, "I remain convinced that fighting against bail reform was a mistake." Not to belabor the point, but isn't this pretty much what I've been writing on this blog for the past 5 years?
Indeed, this particular fight was apparently a nine million dollar mistake.
The article also mentions that the county fired their big shot lawyers. You remember them? They're the ones that the insurance companies said were going to stop bail reform altogether.
Again I call your attention to ABC's declaration recently that the Third Generation of Bail Reform has "imploded." This is about as far from implosion as you can get.
I'll conclude with something I wrote in my very first document about bail -- bail reform is inevitable. And yes, accordingly, it's a mistake to fight it. I think the insurance companies know that (although it's hard to tell what they actually know about bail), but they continue to fight perhaps because they understand the future of release and detention in America has no room for them. Theoretically, at least, there is (or maybe was) room for bail agents, but it looks like all of the fighting is really beginning to backfire on the entire industry.
Winter is coming.
Showing posts with label Harris County. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Harris County. Show all posts
Tuesday, January 8, 2019
Thursday, August 31, 2017
A Tipping Point in Bail Reform?
I should have spent a bit
more time talking about the Conference of Chief Justices’ brief in the Harris
County case because it really is remarkable. You can find it here.
Remember that Harris County
was sued in federal court over its bail practices, which were built upon the Texas bail laws. In a preliminary injunction, the federal district
court judge essentially said that the way Harris County was using money bail
violated the U.S. Constitution.
Now normally if that
happened in any other area of the law, you’d see all the other states join
together with Texas and say, “Whoa, now, we don’t need a federal court telling
us how to do stuff – back off and we’ll take care of it in our court system.”
And in most other areas of the law, the federal court might think, “Well, maybe
I should just defer to the states on this one.”
But when it comes to bail and
no bail, the Conference of Chief Justices – made up of the chief justice in
every state, D.C., and American territories – essentially said the opposite. It
said, “No, we actually need some help from the federal court because, “Despite
general consensus and some notable reform, the promise of equal pretrial
treatment for indigent defendants remains elusive.” In fact, it said, “Current
bail reform practices will remain largely stalled pending clearly articulated
constitutional principles that protect public safety and the pretrial rights of
indigent defendants.”
The CCJ wrote that
technically it wasn’t taking any sides, but then it came right out and wrote:
“The Fourteenth Amendment prohibits the use of monetary bail that results in
the detention of indigent defendants solely due to inability to pay.” There’s a reason why ABC went on a rant after
the CCJ filed its brief, basically calling the justices liars (or “half”
liars), blind to the truth, and arrogant (by the way, great strategy, ABC!). Of
all the amicus briefs, this is the one that flattens the bail industry. This brief
might irritate you, ABC, but you brought it on yourself by fighting the justices at every turn. This generation of reform could have been defined by the bail industry helping the states and the chief justices to find the answers; instead, you all turned it into a war with you versus everyone else.
To me, the only thing holding back the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals from affirming the district court would
be some concern that it might be infringing on an area that the states felt
they could handle. In this brief, the CCJ says, “Go ahead – you’re not infringing
and we actually need it.”
If there’s a tipping point in
this generation of American bail reform, then August 9, 2017, the day when
every chief justice in America asked the federal courts to set limits on how the states
use money bail, might just be it.
Thursday, May 11, 2017
Bail Insurance Company “Experts” in Harris County
In my last blog, I showed how
the bail insurance companies didn’t even know what the word “bail” meant.
That’s a big deal – the amicus in which they screwed up in Houston was written
for the case in Georgia by some big shot appellate lawyer. They paid him big
money – so they got a big mistake.
Now let’s see how the bail
insurance companies fared with their “expert” witnesses in Harris County. They
had two. The first is pretty easy to dismiss. The court found that even though
he might have known a bit about the history of the Harris County Court back
when he worked there, he’d been retired for six years and so his testimony was
given “substantially less weight” than contradictory testimony.
The second “expert” really requires
a bit of an explanation, but I’ll save that explanation just in case the bail
insurance dudes decide (unwisely) to use him again. Suffice it to say that this
second guy is a bail insurance lackey (he’s been one since 2010) apparently with an
incredible bias toward making sure those companies look good at any cost. But
don’t trust me – just read what the court said about him. As you do, remember
that when we legal types say something “isn’t credible,” it means we don’t
believe it.
“His method for arriving at
that number is not clear . . . [therefore, the other expert’s] calculation . .
. is the more reliable figure.”
“[His] criticism is not
credible . . . [and is] particularly weak given his own analytical shortcomings
in studying Harris County’s data.”
“The defendants dispute these
numbers, but their expert . . . provided no alternative figures.”
“The defendant’s expert . . .
attempted a different method of counting. His study is critically flawed in at
least two ways.”
“An even more basic flaw in
[his] study was his exclusion of all misdemeanor defendants who had ‘moderate’
or ‘high’ risk scores from the population he considered. In sum, [he] excluded
indigent defendants from his survey to conclude that, of the misdemeanor
defendants surveyed, none was detained because of indigence. [This] conclusion
is not entitled to any weight.”
“These critical flaws
undermine his credibility and diminishes the court’s confidence in the
reliability of the opinions he expressed, whether deriving from his own
research or criticizing the analytic methods and conclusions of others.”
Ouch.
“[His] attempt to salvage his
report is not successful.”
“[His] decision to
disaggregate his findings by gender and provide no overall failure rates is
puzzling, to say the least. His decision to disaggregate his findings had the
effect of inflating the slight difference in failure rates . . . and made it
appear greater than the overall rate of failure, which [he] did not provide.”
“His [Dallas Study] is
entitled to substantially less weight than the published, peer-reviewed
articles in the record.”
Wow. Enough already. Do you
get it? He doesn’t know what he’s talking about when he talks about other
research, and he doesn’t know what he’s talking about when he’s talking about his own research. And that stuff about
inflating the rates? That’s his incredible bias to try to find some conclusion
that supports the insurance companies.
I can’t blame this so-called
expert for falling under the spell of the bail insurance companies. They offer
people boatloads of money and fame – a weird kind of bail fame that comes from
having your work immediately thrust into the national spotlight. Other people
fall for that, too. The problem is that now
that he’s been ridiculed in court, the bail insurance companies will just go
hunt for some other patsy willing to say anything for all that money and bail fame.
Once again, bail agents, you
need to unshackle yourselves from the bail insurance companies. Yeah, they got
the county to appeal, but that’s just to buy time to settle. The appeal on this
single motion (this is not the trial – it’s just an incredibly huge motion
hearing before the trial) will cost a ton more money in just legal fees, and
then, even if they win, they’ll just end up in trial with the same judge, the same evidence, and the same expert.
You bail agents in America
have to consider removing that word “agent” from your title. You’ve got to find
someone who understands how the insurance companies’ protracted “fight
everything” strategy won’t work – especially when what they did in Harris
County is the best they can do. When you find that person, tell him or her that
you want to remain in business, but that you know that might mean changing your
business practices. The insurance companies are on their way out in American
bail. Your choice is between letting them go down on their own, or letting them
take you down with them.
Thursday, May 4, 2017
ABC Doesn't Even Know What Bail Is
So I'm perusing the Harris County memorandum and opinion in the federal case, and I see a footnote in which the court says, "Texas's scheme points up a flaw in the amicus brief filed by the American Bail Coalition [and others]. The brief consistently and ahistorically assumes that references to 'bail' always mean a secured money bail with a monetary payment required up front as a condition of release." That's "a-historically," as in, going against or ignorant of history.
Thats 's a pretty big flaw, because it means the bail insurance companies -- the group developing the strategy to keep money bail in America -- doesn't even know what bail is. This flaw is the basis for a lot of the bail insurance companies' flawed legal claims, by the way, and it's the same flaw advanced by the big time law firm they've hired to litigate these cases.
I've written about this many times before, and they've got no excuse because everything the court said about bail -- what it is and what it isn't -- has been spelled out in my papers. But they refuse to read my papers. I'll let you decide whether that's wise. As the federal court in Harris County said, bail is a mechanism of release. As my papers say, bail is a process of release. We have a thing called bail to release people, just as we have a thing called "no bail" to provide a way to detain them. It's really pretty simple.
Bail agents, the insurance companies are not only losing this thing for you, they're losing it without even bothering to figure out what they're even talking about.
One day, as you're turning off the lights one final time, you'll probably think to yourself, "I suppose before we just followed along with the insurance companies' lost cause, we should've at least checked to see if they could correctly define the word bail."
Just in case, in my next blog I'll define the words "American" and "Coalition."
Thats 's a pretty big flaw, because it means the bail insurance companies -- the group developing the strategy to keep money bail in America -- doesn't even know what bail is. This flaw is the basis for a lot of the bail insurance companies' flawed legal claims, by the way, and it's the same flaw advanced by the big time law firm they've hired to litigate these cases.
I've written about this many times before, and they've got no excuse because everything the court said about bail -- what it is and what it isn't -- has been spelled out in my papers. But they refuse to read my papers. I'll let you decide whether that's wise. As the federal court in Harris County said, bail is a mechanism of release. As my papers say, bail is a process of release. We have a thing called bail to release people, just as we have a thing called "no bail" to provide a way to detain them. It's really pretty simple.
Bail agents, the insurance companies are not only losing this thing for you, they're losing it without even bothering to figure out what they're even talking about.
One day, as you're turning off the lights one final time, you'll probably think to yourself, "I suppose before we just followed along with the insurance companies' lost cause, we should've at least checked to see if they could correctly define the word bail."
Just in case, in my next blog I'll define the words "American" and "Coalition."
Monday, May 1, 2017
Money Bail Loses in Harris County, Texas
Those of us out changing bail across America over the weekend already saw this, but if you're just waking up, the federal judge in Harris County ruled that "Harris County's policy and practice violates the Equal Protection and Due Process Clauses of the United States Constitution." What policy and practice is that? It's the traditional money bail system used in jurisdictions all over the country.
The memorandum and opinion is long, but you can read it here.
I'll have more in the future on this, only because it was mostly the bail insurance companies trying to run this litigation. They provided the experts (which were trashed in the opinion), and they supplied all the faulty legal arguments. In fact, you can see that the County was out of its depth through what various county officials said on the record. But this loss isn't a loss for Harris County -- it'll survive and eventually make appropriate changes. But the bail insurance companies are going to have to go back to the old drawing board.
Additionally, and to their credit, many criminal justice leaders in Harris County agreed even before the hearing that the system there was unfair and unconstitutional. That's happening all over the U.S.
Let the spin begin. The bail insurance companies will now be trying to convince the county to appeal. It shouldn't, as it will lead to a tremendous amount of money spent on a futile cause. They'll also try to convince bail agents that, in the end, they'll win. So expect an appeal for more of your money as well.
I've worked in law for a dang long time, and I've worked for federal courts. I've never seen anyone put more time and money into a motions hearing than the bail insurance companies did in this one. But, you see, you can't lobby federal judges. You can't change the constitution. And, in the end, you can't hold on to an inherently unfair money bail system.
Labels:
ABC,
bail reform,
Harris County,
money bail,
PBUS
Monday, December 19, 2016
Harris County Bail Case
The bail insurance companies have been traveling around the country trying to convince people that their briefs in the 11th Circuit show how the law is on their side in these federal lawsuits.
Three days ago, though, the Federal District Court for the Southern District of Texas filed a memorandum and opinion in a suit against Harris County over its bail practices. In that 78 page opinion, the Chief Judge disagreed with several of the same claims you'll find in the 11th Circuit briefs. Rational basis instead of strict scrutiny? Dead! Use 8th Amendment analysis rather than Equal Protection? Dead! Younger abstention? Dead! Neidermeyer . . . ? You get the gist.
Next up is a motion for preliminary injunction in the Harris County case -- you know, the thing the plaintiffs won in the 11th Circuit that forms the basis of that interlocutory appeal.
The insurance company lobbyists like to claim that all the previous settlements are due to the small jurisdictions begin overwhelmed, but you wait and see. Once plaintiff's attorneys start deposing the defendants, including judges, even a big place like Harris County is going to find settling simply to follow the law much more palatable.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



